13K views 3 years ago We take a look at two main reasons that Amish & Mennonite women wear head coverings. I believe we must accept the scripture everywhere without forcing the language and then handle the 'damage' to our own ideas after the fact, as well as resolve any seeming contradictions without twisting the original statements. The women's head covering is one of the most important doctrines in the Amish and Mennonite churches. That is because that is the one where I have struggled the most but also the one where God has revealed Himself so clearly to me. Why do Mennonites wear head coverings? To cover the top of the head, it is made up of cloth. The Bible commands women to cover their heads when praying, and by the mid-19th century, bonnets had become the standard headwear for Mennonites. I'm interested to know what you think wearing a head covering signifies in today's western cultureare you suggesting it has no cultural significance? It is still worn by the Amish, and by many Mennonites and Brethren. Women may wear dresses or head coverings. One good way to point to the error is that women who wear plain clothing are also subject to assault. , Amish Wedding Customs and Traditions , A Day in the Life of an Amish Woman , Growing Up on an Amish Farm as an Amish Child , Amish Food - Traditional Amish recipes , My Testimony of Leaving the Amish. Sadly, though, this God-ordained headship order is looked upon with disdain and discontent by many today. Source: https://justplaincooking.ca . I appreciate your generosity in sharing. Mennonites wear bonnets as part of their religious tradition. Not sure how he would describe his visible symbols. (Numbers 6:18, NIV). We are members at Lime Rock Mennonite Church west of Lititz. I love them as Christian sisters. But I was also a little worried, as any memoir writer with extended family in the room will be! We would like to show you a description here but the site won't allow us. Those who shun cell phones, computers . I battled over this Scripture for many weeks and couldn't seem to come to a conclusion as to what this Scripture was saying. Then Consider Checking: We are the online marketplace for Old Order Amish families who live and skillfully weave high-quality handmade wicker baskets in an Amish community in the Heartland. Last week I asked Kathy to respond to some questions specifically about the prayer covering she puts on every day. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. Being Mennonite does not mean one has to avoid technology. It may be that the times are a-changin or it may be that different Old Order groups are different in their practices, even now. Sexual assault is not about what the victim is wearing, how they were acting, where they were or even whether they were drinking. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. The practice of wearing the Kapp is directly taken from the bible as mentioned in Corinthians. On the other hand, I have a real problem with this: to protect oneself against sexual temptations or attacks. I have a different perspective on what is meant by head covering in the passage referenced, but honor the choice that Kathy and others make from their convictions. A womans hair symbolizes her beauty and is something that should be kept for her husbands viewing. But Godchose my family, my home, and theculture and placed me here for such a time as this. AsI live my life for God as an adult, I choose to follow thescriptural teaching of wearing a head covering. A white bonnet is typically worn if the Amish woman is married. A third reason why I cover my head is to rest in the protection that is referred to in Verse 10 of this same chapter. So the question arose, "Will they go to heaven?" I am a Quaker who covers, and while I had never articulated it, that statement about protecting oneself against sexual temptations holds truth for me. But I have concluded that making a doctrine and law out of this issue is wrong. Headcovering, at least during worship services, is still promoted or required in a few denominations and among the more traditional Catholics.Among these are Catholics who live a plain life and are known as Plain Catholics. Folder's list view has different sized fonts in different folders. I'm not sure why they have a different style? The Mennonite tradition of dressing simply and conservatively, including wearing dresses for women and girls, stems from a desire to live out their faith commitments. You may ask, "Why does she have to wear a head covering all the time and not only when she's praying?" Over time and among different groups Mennonite womens head coverings were intended to serve the same function: modesty, conformity to the church and separation from society, based on teachings in I Corinthians 11:3-15. Lets look at Mennonite vs Amish head coverings and see how we can distinguish them from each other. The more mid-western Amish communities and the. Really its about looking good for the opposite sex, or what takes the least amount of time to get ready in the morning, or suits your career image, etc. A kapp ( /kp/, Pennsylvania German from German Kappe meaning cap, cover, hood) is a Christian headcovering worn by many women of certain Anabaptist Christian denominations (especially among Mennonites, Amish, Schwarzenau Brethren and River Brethren of the Old Order Anabaptist and Conservative Anabaptist traditions), as well as certain Coverings and Bonnets, Amish, Quaker, and Mennonite Stories: Part Two, Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), The Mindful Grandparent: The Art of Loving Our Childrens Children, Blush: A Mennonite Girl Meets a Glittering World, Mennonite Bonnet and Covering Stories: Part One, Coverings and Bonnets, Part Three: Church of the Brethren and Quaker Stories , http://fox43.com/2014/02/26/former-amish-woman-writes-second-memoir-bonnet-strings, Why Wear a Head Covering: Brethren and a Quaker Stories | Shirley Hershey Showalter, What Do Mennonite Women Wear? And now I want to go back to the article itself to make sure I didnt misinterpret the idea of protection, which was cited by some of the interviewees. 551 views Feb 3, 2022 Amish and Mennonite women always have a head covering. The Old Order Mennonites worship in a meeting house thats specially built for praise and worship. You may have noticed that Amish and Mennonite women all wear a covering of some sort on their heads. I honestly felt like God would not hear me if I did not have my head covered. It is a comfort to know that Gods ministering angels, and even Satans angels of darkness, take note of my headship veiling. [She shall be like a tree planted by the rivers of water.]. Her husband Jay is a real partner and together they live their faith every day. "Signpost" puzzle from Tatham's collection. I'm leaving a link here where you can find photos of the numerous different styles of head coverings that Amish women wear. And for pointing out that many women who do not wear coverings share a similar interpretation of I Corinthians 11 when it talks about headship. The reading suggests that women who pray with an uncovered head dishonor the religion. It is a privilege, to not be completely dominated by Satan in this wicked world. Amish women wear this all day long, taking it off only to wash and comb their hair. The Amish Kapp is a thin fabric like the Mennorite head covering but is covered by a bonnet. Hijabi women -- particularly those that are racialized -- also experience racism and Islamophobia. I hope your readers enjoy getting to know Kathy. In the exhibit, stereotypes and assumptions in North American society about head coverings worn by Muslim women are addressed. Mennonites, however, can resemble your everyday American; complete with modern technology and, when compared to the Amish, a more relaxed dress code. For some of us, that means we dont follow the latest fashions that might lean in the direction of provocative, and for other women it may mean wearing a head covering and plain dress. But some of the stricter Amish women have to wear it anytime they leave home. The display reflects that, in reality, Muslim women represent so much variation and contrast within and beyond their communities. Why Wear a Covering Its a German word meaning cap and is donned by Mennonite women whenever they leave the house or during prayer. Do Muslim head coverings and Mennonite bonnets provoke the same response? Jun 25, 2018 Mennonites are a group of people who belong to a sect of Christianity. Other rules on lifestyle also vary depending on the church. But the Amish people are often more concerned with keeping the traditions than they are in actually figuring out what God wants them to do. Thanks for bringing us the view from Qatar, Warm Ginger. My group of Russian Orthodox believers still do this. Yes, Laurie. When a man shoulders his responsibility, it enables the woman to find security and gives her opportunity to reach her greatest potential. The black bonnets are worn by the women who arent married and this signifies their relationship status. Each Amish district is made of around 150 people and will have its bishop, deacon, and ministers, while the Old Order Mennonites have smaller districts with fewer church authorities. First, a veil which is worn by Mennonite women and also some Amish "when doing tasks that might damage the shaped white covering": A covering worn by unmarried girls to church: And its description: And finally a covering worn by some girls while working: Its simple design is practical: Of course these scriptures, addressing the headship order, do not mean that husbands and fathers are to by tyrants, or rule over their wives and daughters in a disrespectful manner. They avoided wearing jewelry, fashionable clothing or . There are many things that they do simply because that's how they have always done it. Why do they do this, and what does it represent? My familys response filled my heart with joy that night. ie: "or that a man can't be a hippie. We always were taught that uncut hair is a covering, although some mexican apostolics would still wear head coverings. I love Kathys response and feel many parallels between her thoughts as a Mennonite and my own as a secular feminist. In general men look silly with long hair (with some exceptions) and in general women look beautiful with long, flowing, gorgeous hair (with some exceptions). Frankly my biggest worry nowadays for Amish and Mennonites everywhere is that if everything is invested in Acts as a result the Great Commission is neglected. However, their style of head coverings are similar, and that can make them difficult to tell apart. as unable to control themselves. They believe that a woman having her head covered is a sign that she is in submission to her husband. I admire your clarity of purpose. Jesus broke some of the traditions of the time such as hand washing or eating grain gleaned on sabbath, and he even worked on the sabbath (healing others) instead of making them suffer for another day. Some may wear an old covering that they don't care if it gets smushed and wrinkly. The passage indicates submission to God and women praying without an end. Prayer coverings, are worn by women to cover their hair and are typically black or white. Not every Amish community abides by the same rules or standard of living. In a man's case his headship is not in this world but invisible, so when praying to God the open air is a better symbol. AMAZON DISCLOSURE: I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. . I am what you would term English but believe that my husband is the head of my family. Why then do head coverings receive so much public attention? No, it is not always easy to be submissive. However, there are some conservative sects of Mennonites that dress in a way to encourage modesty and separation from society. I am going to weigh in here on the issue that Renita raised. Head Covering as a Common Practice. Rhonda, on a cold and blustery day the idea of a warm hug is especially appealing. Its good to have your voice here. Let's look at the Apostles meaning, this well then explain why in many churches this practice has ceased. I do not believe that the way I dress or whether or not I wear a prayer covering changes my risk against attack, and I agree that that suggestion falls closely towards victim shaming. We as women should not have all the responsibility for how men relate to us, but I think we need to take part of that responsibility by being aware of the carriage of our being. What was the early churches view on head-covering for women? 44624 I have written elsewhere about Anabaptist Theology and Violence against Women, a theme to which I recently returned in a recent talk at the Womens Doing Theology conference. I was single until I was 37 years old and let some of that fear bind me. Morlock teaches dress and diversity at Ryerson Universitys School of Fashion in Toronto. Why Should Women Submit? Am I warm and welcoming to anyone I meet? Covering your head ensures that you arent offending God by attracting any attention. Therefore, I think Paul is now referring to something here that is 'not cultural'. Today in most countries we can do whatever we please, even die our hair purple or green and no particular cultural message is being communicated that would be necessarily offensive to Paul. However to properly understand this phenomena of changing practices I think it is necessary to understand Paul's literal teaching. Their answer would be that a person must always be ready to pray. The question of whether women should wear a head covering is another question. Mennonite women used to wear coverings or prayer veils on their heads all the time and dressed plainly, wearing conservative clothing and no make-up or jewelry. Kathy Wenger's sister and mother at the BLUSH book launch. Verse 4 of 1 Corinthians 11 states that it dishonors Christ if a man prays with his head covered. In conservative communities, this can mean head coverings that resemble bonnets. I expect you would also agree that plain clothing does not protect a woman if a man is intent on abuse. to witness to the world to open conversations about faith. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. Women in progressive Mennonite communities and congregations might don t-shirts and shorts, but one can expect those shorts to reach mid-thigh or lower, and shirts will not reveal cleavage. Black cotton head wear for women, elasticated bonnet with long ties, full head covering, lined head scarf, headwear 5 out of 5 stars (3.8k) Judge in yourselves: is it comely that a woman prays unto God uncovered? The elitest and the powerful political type they control use this power more so than ever, especially in the USA to control the masses. The more mid-western Amish communities and the Amish outside of America wear a more straight pleated design. I promised to offer this space also as a forum for other perspectives. There are different standards of dress for men than for women and, while head coverings symbolize non-conformity to society, they are a symbol of conformity within the group, even though there is diversity between Mennonite groups when it comes to the style of head coverings! The answer is two-fold. They will not appear online until approved and will be posted during business hours. I felt like it wasn't a big deal to God, whether I cover my head or not. As it turned out, my worry was displaced. The head covering that Mennonites wear is known as a Haube. First, Paul in referring to nature is simply pointing out what most people realize. To Paul one should become 'a Jew to a Jew and Gentile to a Gentile', therefore if a given culture communicated submission to her husband by wearing a purple cone on her head, a Christian woman in that culture should also wear a purple cone on her head. In fact, until the 20th century no Reformed theologian taught against head coverings for women in public worship. Than you for allowing me to share why I wear a headship veiling. Then she focuses on the opportunity to be . Doth not even nature itself teach you, that if a man has long hair, it is a shame unto him? to show uniformity in having a consistent witness with other women. Black bonnets are worn by female Mennonites that are unmarried, signifying that they are open and interested in obtaining a husband (while married women generally wear white bonnets) Why do Mennonites cover their faces when they pray? Men wear plain suits and dress shirts. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. 16. These posts have been fascinating reading for me Shirley. A head covering or hat for women seems to have been a cultural thing in numerous countries for many years. For example, the Nazirite was instructed to go against this symbolism as a revised symbol of his 'dedication'. Head coverings have caricatured Muslims, and served to collapse a group of people into one identity, and project onto Islam an anti-woman stereotype, while lifting the veil has been seen as a metaphor for freedom and democracy.. Thank you for doing careful research, respectful of all women. They believe that a woman having her head covered is a sign that she is in submission to her husband. These Amish bonnets have been written about in Holy Scriptures and this is why their significance is understood in the hearts of Amish people. Though most Protestant denominations have no official expectation that women cover, some individuals choose to practice headcovering according to their understanding of 1 Corinthians 11. Verse 10. Amish Church (What is Amish Church Like? Rather, as a bald woman was a great cultural shame back then, and that not keeping her head covered was interpreted as rebellion, the natural images of nature should not at all be rebelled against. I knew they each had taken the opposite path. It feels like there is so much I need todo to be agodly woman. Many men have neglected or abused their authority; while many woman say they feel degraded and deprived. entertainment, news presenter | 4.8K views, 31 likes, 13 loves, 80 comments, 2 shares, Facebook Watch Videos from GBN Grenada Broadcasting Network: GBN News 28th April 2023 Anchor: Kenroy Baptiste. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Amish and Mennonite women always have a head covering. A bonnet is worn over this covering whenever the women need to go outside their homes or into the church. These bonnets can either be black or white, each symbolizing its meaning. Mennonites are a group of Christians who often wear head coverings. It was ingrained into my very being that this is something I MUST do. While Mennonites who wear head coverings may experience discrimination due to being a visible minority, they benefit from White Christian privilege (see "White Christian Privilege" by Khyati Joshi). The majority of Mennonite traditions and practices center around serving and honoring God while remaining humble and modest. Single women are under the authority of their fathers or church leaders. Like yes, God said X, the latest Gallup poll said Y, so, huh, God must have been wrong. But after listening to one pastor, I concluded that the head covering needs to be worn, with my head covered completely, only while praying or prophesying in a public assembly. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Could a subterranean river or aquifer generate enough continuous momentum to power a waterwheel for the purpose of producing electricity? This particular group wears a different head covering compared to the Amish. Warm hug, Rhonda. Thanks for Asking Why do Amish and Mennonite women wear head coverings? document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Shirley Hershey Showalter | Hosting by Clay Showalter. Bible times regarding head dress were not that different than various places in the Middle East today, where the social meaning is the same (or similar) as it was at the time of Christ. In the ongoing balancing act of DOing and BEing, even though Im a very active person, I relish BEing. Even though the men don't wear hats during prayer, they ensure that they have one wherever they go. The bonnet, however, is usually black and is worn as an outer covering. Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically. Though practices have changed, the scriptural significance remains, and the blessings of wearing the covering are abundant. But if a woman has long hair, it is a glory to her: for her hair is given her for a covering. Ive invited the researcher Beth E. Graybill to speak to this issue. Rather than engage in rampant consumerism, the Amish would much rather craft their own goods, like. The short answer is that women started to see it as an elective fashion and the fashion changed. To answer the question: Do Muslim head coverings and Mennonite bonnets provoke the same response? Mennonites were not the first ones to use head coverings, and there are many cultures around the world that still use them today. As Shirley points out, the responsibility to police behavior is solely on the abuser. Paul argues it is a natural symbol that shows a woman under the headship of the man. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. This is what I mean by hypersexualized. , theyre usually speaking about the Old-colony Mennonites. Beingseparated by dress is a visible symbol, but trulybeing transformed by the work of God and hisSon Jesus calls me toshow Himself to others. Hanging veils and scarves must cover at least from the crown of the head to the bottom of the hair bun. Even though He holds this lofty position, and shares in the Godhead, Jesus Christ submits to the authority of God, His Father (John 8:16; 14:28; Mark 13:31-33). I feel happiest, most confident, safest, and most respected with my kapp on. However, in more liberal groups, these coverings are smaller and often lacier. Comments are moderated and may be edited. Which makes you a resonator for others. And I thought that I might go to hell if I didn't wear a covering. "I believe we must accept the scripture everywhere without forcing the language and then handle the 'damage' to our own ideas after the fact." But ironies abound, as the exhibit points out. Some Mennonites also avoid certain haircuts or styles. So here are some coverings for special circumstances. It seems only fair that both should speak. What positional accuracy (ie, arc seconds) is necessary to view Saturn, Uranus, beyond? Why is this the case? Where does the version of Hamapil that is different from the Gemara come from? The Amish people try to obey every command in the Bible and they take them literally. Christian leaders believed the head covering called for in 1 Corinthians signified women's modesty and submission, so they continued to wear whatever type of covering was in fashion at the. Certain clothes are meant to be sexy or provocative in this culture that is hypersexualized. Women can wear a covering and a cape dress, but have a hard face and a bitter spirit. Similarly, men and women hold equally important positions; but God asks women to be submissive to the authority of men. When an Amish man isnt married, hes required to constantly shave his facial hair until hes found a woman to call his wife. used with permission, This information is also available in pamphlet form. In the light of all that has been said, the first and most important reason I wear a covering, is that it is a visible symbol of my acceptance of Gods order of authority. My children are taught that their dad is the spiritual head of the family. Hi, Im Anna. One must realize woman should keep their head covered in these places otherwise it is seen as a huge protests against a woman's submission to her husband. But, in answer to the question, "Should women wear a head covering?" I will never say that it's wrong for a woman to wear a prayer veil. Why Do Mennonites Wear Dresses. The cap or veil I wear on my head is a headship veiling, commonly called a covering. Women wear cape dresses at the knee or below. It is still worn by the Amish, and by many Mennonites and Brethren. Is Scripture saying that we should wear a covering over our long hair? Saloma, thanks for this candid assessment of how fashion and individual responsibility (both mens and womens) come together. Maybe she and others have comments about how Holdeman dress styles have been changing in recent years, and perhaps hazard a guess as to what that means? The Covering The Home Place Farmhouse -- Now Forgotten Seasons. Africa ranks#1 with the most Mennonites and the United States is number two. That is the same church we go to although not many have the black bumpers anymore. There are variations of head coverings in the different Amish communities. Ive often wondered what part of the beliefs has to change to leave this practice and youre the first one to explain. Gradually the practice has been lost by all but a few churches. Christianity Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for committed Christians, experts in Christianity and those interested in learning more. You have a gift for pulling out the words that resonate. But after we completely left the Mennonite church, and I was the only woman in church wearing a head covering, I began questioning this passage very deeply. It may surprise you to know that the practice of wearing a veiling did not originate with those who continue to wear it today. And they usually wear something on their head at night as well. Why do Mennonites not wear wedding rings? Both of them wear head coverings. This sounds like an interesting exhibit -- thank you for writing an article about it so that those of us unable to attend can appreciate it from afar! Should I re-do this cinched PEX connection? I understand what you are saying and appreciate your thoughts on this. If a woman does not cover her head, she should have her hair cut off; Why don't more Christian women wear a covering? But this Scripture passage is why they believe that every woman must have her head covered to pray. Why rebel against a cultural ceremony if it even has some support in nature? to show nonconformity to the world. Then at the entrance to the tent of meeting, the Nazirite must shave off the hair that symbolizes their dedication. The Old Order and Old-colony Mennonites cooperate with the Amish in having shared educational environments and fields of crops. An exhibit called Un/Coverings: Mennonite & Muslim Womens Heads and Hearts, now on display until April at Schneider Haus National Historic Site, in Kitchener, Ont., explores these questions.